mac5's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Cliff 2004]

Very good!

This is an excellent piece. Great mix of ambient/techno. Keep up the great work!

I give you a low diversity score as a good thing -- too much diversity (10), is a bad thing for me. I like songs which stick to a certain tune, and occasionally change. 1 or 0 is too low for my liking, so i think that 5 fits your piece.

Just one thing...when the song is ending, and it's becomming ambient again, you might want to make it loopable -- just a suggestion. If someone wanted to use this in a flash game or something, having it be loopable would be a big booster.

Other than that, excellent!

I have no more to say.

ChasmyrSS responds:

Hmmm, a loopable version wouldn't be a bad idea, I'd probably have to cut the beginning and end differently. I'll look at posting a second version! Thanks for the review!

[Metropolis]

Interesting...

I enjoyed this piece to a certain extent...although I do think you could change a few things -- don't get me wrong, this is very good, and everyone has their own style and preference. In my opinion, this had a bit too much tune diversity; I found that once you finally found a tune and pattern that worked, the song had come to an end. Very nice transfer from the beginning slow part to the fast part, though. I really liked that.

Keep working! You definitely have talent!

RoboX responds:

Thanks ^-^